Hands reviewing detailed mechanical engineering drawings and technical diagrams alongside small car models.

What can entrepreneurs learn from filing more than 100 patents and patent applications? Filing for patents involves more than protecting an invention. It requires careful planning, precise documentation, and an understanding of how intellectual property can support long-term business growth. Drawing on his experience as a named inventor on more than 100 patents and patent applications, Paresh Patel shares lessons about identifying problems worth solving, understanding the importance of filing timelines, and working with knowledgeable patent counsel to establish meaningful protection.

Through his experience developing PayRange and introducing mobile payment technology into traditionally cash-dependent industries, he explains why patent claims matter, how individual inventions can contribute to a broader patent portfolio, and why intellectual property strategy should evolve alongside a company’s technology. Ultimately, successful patent protection means looking beyond the immediate invention and considering how today’s decisions can safeguard innovation, support future development, and strengthen a company’s competitive position.

 


 

I’ve been named as an inventor on more than 100 patents and patent applications over the course of my career. Each one represents a problem that needed solving. Sometimes they were one-offs, but more often than not, they were part of a much larger effort to improve some everyday experience that caused frustration.

Over those 100+ applications, I’ve come to appreciate just how much thought goes into protecting an invention. The process begins long before an application is submitted, and every decision you make along the way can have implications years after a patent is granted. I’ve spent much of my career developing technology for industries that move extremely slowly to adopt it, which has changed how I think about innovation and intellectual property.

When you’re trying to make a digital transformation in an established industry, you’re often butting up against technical limitations that don’t have existing solutions. Every little step you take becomes part of a much larger system, and your initial invention may create value far beyond the original idea.

For entrepreneurs working on or considering filing for patents, I’d like to share several lessons from my own experience.

 

The Best Inventions Begin With Problems Worth Solving

 

I started my first vending business at age 17 with a used soda machine I bought from a local garage. I grew that business into thousands of operating machines, and the experience taught me more about identifying opportunities than any education or observation I had.

As I operated the vending machines, I became familiar with all the little things that affected the business. A machine breaks down. That’s an obvious one, and the answer is that someone has to fix it. A customer has trouble completing a purchase. Well, there could be any number of issues, and ultimately, it means you’ve probably lost a sale. If I wanted to know how a particular location was performing, I usually had to go in person and audit the machine by hand.

These were just the operating realities of the industry, and they had existed for decades. The equipment worked well enough to vend, so the incentives to innovate on the systems around them were almost nonexistent. I largely accepted them until an experience made me see things from a consumer’s point of view. I was short a few spare coins on a transaction I really needed to make. I felt so frustrated in that moment, but I learned something important.

 

“I had spent years operating machines that depended on cash, but I hadn’t really interacted with them as a customer. At one point, an outdated payment system prevented my sale. That experience inspired PayRange, which I founded to bring mobile payments to machines that had traditionally relied on cash and coins.”

 

The original idea was straightforward. People should be able to use their phones to pay for things without fumbling around for exact change. Simple. But developing the technology to make that possible required solving a range of technical problems across different types of equipment. And that’s the crux of invention. Recognizing an unmet need gives you a reason to develop something, but the process of figuring out how to solve the problem is where the patentable innovation starts to emerge.

My background as an operator helped me understand what the solution needed to accomplish to be useful. I knew the economics of the business and the limitations of existing equipment. I also knew how difficult it could be to get operators to adopt new technology. Solving the problem had to account for all of those realities.

 

Why Does Timing Matter When Filing for Patents?

 

One of the most unsurprising lessons I’ve learned about filing for patents is that timing can determine if an invention is protectable. We’ve all heard the historical anecdotes of two brilliant people filing nearly identical inventions within days or hours of each other. It happened with the telephone, the light bulb, and even the microchip.

How does this happen? When entrepreneurs are developing a product, their attention is usually directed toward getting it to work. They’re testing ideas and making improvements. They’re market testing the product with potential customers and prepping the whole thing for launch. During that time, the patent process might be a can that keeps getting kicked down the road. 

The United States operates under a first-inventor-to-file system, which favors the inventor with the earliest effective filing date when comparing applications for the same invention. As the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office explains, the system also includes certain exceptions related to public disclosures, but those protections have specific requirements and limitations. Discussing or demonstrating an invention in public before filing can create a whole other host of complications. And in a global marketplace, rules across country borders can be substantially different. An inventor seeking international protection could face limitations once an invention becomes public.

These are important considerations when technology development and go-to-market planning happen simultaneously.

Imagine a company developing a new way for a mobile device to communicate with existing equipment. You want to show that off to prospective customers or investors. There might be pressure to make a new product announcement to capture attention at an event. These are natural activities for building a business, but they also create questions about what information should be shared and when. Patent planning has to be part of those decisions.

That requires communication between the inventor and the people responsible for the company’s IP, usually an attorney. Engineers and inventors need to recognize when their work might be touching on something new, so they can reach out to leadership or counsel to start seeking protection. Keeping records and clear documentation can help explain how a solution works, what problems it addresses, and how it differs from existing approaches. That information is valuable when working with patent counsel to evaluate an invention.

The earlier you recognize a novel IP, the more likely you are to make strong decisions before deadlines limit your protection options.

 

What Details Determine Your Patent Protection?

 

When someone develops a useful invention, they’re usually focused on a specific capability. They know the problem they originally set out to solve, why their invention works, and why someone would want to use it. Patent protection requires translating that technical knowledge into a legal right with specific boundaries. That’s where I’ve learned every word matters.

A patent includes claims that establish the scope of the invention being protected. Those claims use specific language to describe technical elements and novel relationships that the patent must cover. Claim language is central to determining the scope of patent rights and is critical to how they might be interpreted during an infringement dispute.

 

“It’s not uncommon for a specific, individual term to become the focus of a dispute years after a patent has been granted. The description of a particular component or process may affect whether a competing technology or innovation falls within the protection. This makes the quality of the original patent application extremely important.”

 

Let’s think again about the technology required to enable mobile payments on an older vending machine. Making a cashless experience possible may require a specific method of communicating payments to vendors, a unique interface with existing machine controls, and a process for connecting to the mobile device. Every one of those technical solutions needs to be understood on its own merits. A patent application must explain what has been invented and how it’s different from what already exists.

At this point in the discussion, it’s likely clear why I place so much importance on working with knowledgeable patent counsel. Patent law is an extremely specialized field. Just as specialized, in many cases, as the technology being protected. An attorney who understands the legalities but not the invention may have difficulty describing and protecting the most important technical features. The partnership and conversation between the inventor and counsel will undoubtedly affect the resulting application.

Inventors need to be willing and active participants in this process. They should be prepared to explain the engineering decisions behind their work and the technical problems they overcame to reach the goal. Counsel can use that information to develop an appropriate approach for protection. It takes time to get these details right. 

 

Should I Think Beyond a Single Patent?

 

When you pursue technology that represents a digital transformation in an established industry, you often find that the initial problem is actually part of a whole system of challenges that need attention.

We experienced this while building technology for self-service commerce. The goal of allowing someone to pay a machine with a mobile device isn’t easy when the existing equipment wasn’t designed to communicate with smartphones. It also wasn’t designed to interact with digital payment systems. With millions of machines already operating in the field, simply replacing the vending units wasn’t a viable option.

Instead, we had to take on the primary goal in a series of inventive steps. You can see examples of this in our patent portfolio. We had to address a range of technical challenges, including device-to-machine payments and retrofitting existing equipment. 

We also had to make the technology easy for customers to use, simple for operators to install, and secure for every transaction. Adding complexity to the user experience or installation process would’ve been easier, as would building a system with fewer security safeguards. Making all those things work together required considerable behind-the-scenes innovation, so the experience could remain both simple and secure for everyone using it.

That process changed how I think about the scope of intellectual property protection. A single patent may cover one specific part of a larger innovation. Depending on the problem you’re trying to solve, each invention might be a link in a chain that provides underlying architecture, connectivity methods, or completely new functions. Inventors need to understand where the novel thinking lies in each element to determine whether different aspects of the work warrant individual protection.

And this applies beyond your immediate project. It’s not uncommon for an inventor to discover additional applications for their work as they develop the technology. A solution designed for one problem might unlock a breakthrough in another. Knock-on changes to customer behavior or technical requirements might create new problems that weren’t there during development.

Every opportunity for further invention might lead to further patent protection. Now, each application requires resources, so the decision to get protection should have a clear purpose. Make sure that you’re focused on the innovation that adds value to the technology and offers potential long-term strategic benefits to the company. This patent strategy is another area where an experienced attorney can provide counsel.

 

Build Intellectual Property Around the Future of Your Business

 

My time in the technology industry has helped me appreciate how quickly an invention’s application can expand. When I started the idea for PayRange, I was focused on a familiar problem. Vending machines were built for a world of currency that was heading cashless. Solving that problem introduced digital capabilities into equipment that had previously operated with little to no connectivity. Once machines could communicate with digital systems, additional opportunities became apparent.

Cashless payment was just part of a broader digital transformation that needed to happen in self-service commerce. Technology developed to address that one operational limitation became the foundation for changing how the entire business operates. As the systems became connected, we had to solve additional questions about communication, reliability, transaction processing, and cross-device interaction. Adding each new capability introduced technical challenges, which in turn led to further inventions. It was a cycle of innovation.

 

“That development cycle should inform how a company approaches its intellectual property. A patent portfolio can protect the technology that distinguishes a business from its competitors. But it can also support licensing agreements, partnerships, and continued investment in R&D. Protecting the rights associated with these arrangements is another way to derive durable value from your invention.”

 

For a company leading an industry through digital transformation, intellectual property planning needs to account for steering today’s technology toward the direction the business intends to pursue. Stop-gap innovations lose their value rapidly, stressing resources without delivering long-term revenue. Inventors should understand which innovations contribute to the company’s capabilities and become more valuable over time. This can make filing for patents a critical part of a company’s ongoing competitive position.

 

The Responsibility That Comes With Inventing Something Valuable

 

When I think back on my career, I inevitably land on that first vending machine I purchased at 17. I had no idea where that would eventually lead. I definitely had no idea how much technology would revolutionize the industry. But operating those early machines taught me to pay attention to the everyday problems and what they meant for customers and business owners.

Having been named an inventor on more than 100 patents and patent applications, I have a greater appreciation for the decisions that go into meaningful intellectual property protection. Inventors invest time, capital, creativity, and considerable risk into turning their ideas into something useful. That investment deserves protection, particularly when the underlying technology has the potential to support a business for years to come.

If you’re developing a new invention, I encourage you to give intellectual property the same scrutiny and thought you give the technology itself. Seek knowledgeable advice early and consider how today’s decisions may affect your ability to protect that work in the future.

 


 

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

 

1. What should entrepreneurs know before filing for patents?

Filing for patents requires planning well before an invention reaches the market. Entrepreneurs should understand what makes their technology unique, how patent claims define the scope of protection, and how public disclosures may affect their rights. It’s also important to work with experienced patent counsel and consider the long-term costs of maintaining and potentially enforcing a patent. Making these decisions early can help protect the time and resources invested in developing an invention.

2. Why is timing important when filing for patents?

The United States follows a first-inventor-to-file system, which generally gives priority to the inventor with the earlier effective filing date. Waiting too long can create unnecessary risks, particularly if competitors are developing similar technology. Public demonstrations, product announcements, and other disclosures can also affect patent rights. Entrepreneurs should consider patent protection during product development and consult qualified counsel before publicly revealing potentially patentable technology.

3. How do patent claims affect the value of an invention?

Patent claims define the legal boundaries of an invention’s protection. Their wording determines what technology falls within the patent’s scope, which can become particularly important if competitors develop similar products. Even individual terms may affect how a patent is interpreted during a dispute. Precise claims can help establish meaningful protection for valuable technical innovations, making experienced patent counsel an important part of the filing process.

4. Can a single invention require multiple patents?

A complex technology product may include several distinct inventions, each potentially eligible for separate patent protection. For example, a mobile payment system could involve innovations in device communication, transaction processing, and machine connectivity. Filing for patents covering different technical elements may help protect a broader system, provided each claimed invention satisfies patentability requirements. The appropriate strategy depends on the technology, its commercial importance, and the company’s long-term goals.

5. How can patents help a business build a competitive advantage?

Patents give their owners legal rights to exclude others from making, using, selling, offering to sell, or importing the claimed invention within the applicable jurisdiction, subject to the limits of patent law. These rights can help businesses protect differentiated technology, support licensing opportunities, and justify continued investment in research and development. Their commercial value depends on the strength and relevance of the protected inventions. Customer relationships, product quality, distribution, and continued innovation also contribute to a sustainable competitive position.

6. What role do patents play in digital transformation?

Digital transformation often involves developing new technologies that enable established businesses to operate more efficiently or introduce new capabilities. Some of those methods may qualify for patent protection. In self-service commerce, for example, bringing mobile payments and connectivity to traditional machines can involve innovations in equipment interfaces, communication, and transaction processing. Patents can help protect qualifying technical advances while companies continue developing the systems that support modernization.

 

Continue Reading...

Why is the best customer experience often the one customers never notice? An effortless customer experience allows people to complete

How does leadership evolve as a company grows and becomes more complex? Leadership through business growth requires executives to adapt

What should business owners know before adopting cashless payments? Moving away from cash involves much more than choosing payment hardware